Audiovisual authors regret portability agreement ‘holes’
February 21, 2017
By Colin Mann
According to the Society of Audiovisual Authors (SAA) – the association of European collective management organisations representing audiovisual authors – the proposed European Portability Regulation agreement represents a mixed result for collective management organisations for screenwriters and directors: positive as it represents a bonus for consumers which will enable EU residents to travel across Europe with continued access to their subscription services, negative as the final agreement contains holes that risk opening up the Regulation to abuse and eroding the territorial licensing system that underpins the financing of the European audiovisual sector.
While the SAA did not oppose the targeted objective of the Commission proposal, it regrets that the final version of the Regulation does not limit its scope to residents of one EU Member State travelling for a short time to another. Although the definitions of the Member State of residence (where a subscriber has his or her actual and stable residence) and of a temporary presence in another Member State (for a limited period of time) have been improved, SAA is concerned that two key points have been weakened. First, the list of means to verify the Member State of residence includes means that do not guarantee residency on their own (such as a credit card). Second, the possibility for rights holders to authorise the use of content without any verification of the Member State of residence. Given the market power of many services, SAA is unconvinced that many European rights holders would be in a position to refuse.
Cécile Despringre, Executive Director of the SAA said: “This final agreement is not the safe and secure Regulation we believed the Commission, Parliament and Council were aiming to achieve in exchange for a new functionality offered to consumers with no financial benefit to the industry. It will be of utmost importance that this Regulation is carefully monitored in its implementation to identify any abuse.”